The Adriatic club was a member of the National Association of Base Ball Players before the American Civil War. The Adriatics first played another member in September 1857 and joined the NABBP for the 1858 to 1861 seasons.
These are all the Newark Adriatics games listed somewhere by Marshall Wright (2000). For 1857, the game with the Union club of Morrisania, now in the Bronx, is the only listed match versus a non-member club (Adriatic), and the only listed match versus a club outside modern New York City. Only that spring, sixteen clubs within modern New York had convened for the first time, which was later recognized as initiating the Association.
| Date | Opponent | Score | Decision | Record |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| September 25th, 1857 | Morrisania Union | 11-28 | Loss | 0-1 |
| August 5th, 1858 | Morrisania Union | 16-33 | Loss | 0-2 |
| October 28th, 1858 | Brooklyn Pastime | 45-13 | Win | 1-2 |
| July 2nd, 1860 | New York Eagles | 15-18 | Loss | 1-3 |
| August ?, 1860 | Morrisania Union | 8-17 | Loss | 1-4 |
| August 22nd, 1860 | Newark Eurekas | 6-34 | Loss | 1-5 |
| September 6th, 1860 | Brooklyn Charter Oaks | 11-13 | Loss | 1-6 |
| September 19th, 1860 | Newark Eurekas | 12-12 | Tie | 1-6-1 |
| September 5th, 1861 | Newark | 14-17 | Loss | 1-7-1 |
Wright, Marshall D. The National Association of Base Ball Players, 1857-1870. Jefferson, North Carolina: McFarland & Company, Inc. 2000. ISBN 0-7864-0779-4